Why so many brands look the same, and what it costs on the shelf

, 6 min read

Quick answer

Why do so many brands look the same, and what does it cost on the shelf?

Brands look the same because each one copies what already signals the category, tests against the same research and avoids risk. On the shelf the cost is recognition, because a pack that looks like its neighbours has to be read before it can be found. In advertising, System1 with Peter Field and the IPA estimated the extra US media spend needed to make dull ads perform like engaging ones at $189 billion (2024). IW Agency sees the shelf version of that cost hiding in the promotions budget. Keep the category codes that find the shelf and own everything else.

Why do so many brands look the same?

Brand sameness is when competing brands in a category use the same colours, pack shapes, imagery and claims, so a shopper can't tell them apart at a glance. Brands end up looking alike because each one copies what already signals the category, tests against the same research and avoids risk. On the shelf, the cost is recognition. A pack that looks like its neighbours has to be read before it can be found, and many shoppers won't stop to read.

Sameness, sometimes called blandification, rarely comes from one bad decision. It builds up through many sensible ones. A new yoghurt goes white and blue because that is what fresh looks like in the category. A snack adds "less salt" because a competitor did. Each choice lowers the risk for one brand and makes the whole shelf harder to tell apart.

What does sameness cost on the shelf?

Sameness costs a brand the split second in which a shopper recognises it, and with that the sale to anyone not already looking for it. Shoppers find familiar brands by colour and shape before they read a word. When every brand in the category shares those cues, none of them gets credit for them.

The clearest measured price of sameness comes from advertising. System1 defines the cost of dull as the extra media spend needed to make an emotionally flat ad perform as well as an engaging one. In The Extraordinary Cost of Dull (System1 with Peter Field and the IPA, 2024), that cost was estimated at an extra $189 billion in US media spend and £13.29 billion in the UK.

An analysis of the IPA effectiveness database found that dull TV campaigns needed around seven extra points of excess share of voice to grow market share as much as interesting ones (Mi-3, 2024). Adam Morgan of eatbigfish described the proxy for dull as "cases that succeed through rational, logical facts and information."

These figures measure TV advertising, not packs. The same logic applies on the shelf, where a generic pack has to make up the difference through price promotions or extra media. At IW Agency, we think sameness is a cost that hides in the promotions budget.

Conclusion: Looking like the category means paying to be found.

How does a category drift into sameness?

A category drifts into sameness when every brand optimises against the same reference points. Four forces usually push it there:

  1. Category codes. Colours and imagery that signal "this is coffee" get copied until they say nothing about who made the coffee.

  2. Shared research. Brands that ask similar shoppers similar questions reach similar safe answers.

  3. Rational claims. "High in fibre" or "no added sugar" is easy to approve internally and just as easy for a competitor to copy.

  4. Private label imitation. Retailer brands borrow the leader's cues, so the whole shelf moves closer together.

The last force shaped the Swedish cookie aisle. As private labels grew by imitating Swedish cookie classics, the category became crowded, dustier and less engaging. That was the backdrop for our work with Göteborgskex. We cover how leaders respond in how to compete with private labels.

Isn't following category codes just good design?

Some category codes help shoppers find the right shelf. If a brand follows all of them, it becomes interchangeable. The common mistake is treating category cues and brand cues as the same thing.

In rye bread, a category long defined by muted tones and functional messaging, the product had become predictable. Hatting saw an opportunity there, because a category that looks the same leaves room for the brand that doesn't.

Three other misunderstandings come up often:

  • Differentiation and distinctiveness get confused. A better product claim can be true and still look like every other claim. Distinctiveness means being recognised, through assets such as a colour, shape, character or typeface used consistently over time. Ehrenberg-Bass Institute research judges distinctive brand assets on fame (how many people link the asset to the brand) and uniqueness (how few link it to competitors).

  • A redesign doesn't cure sameness by itself. A new pack that follows this year's trend lands next to three others that followed it too.

  • Distinct doesn't mean loud. One owned colour or shape, kept for years, does more than a new pack every season.

Conclusion: Keep the codes that find the shelf. Own everything else.

When should a brand worry about sameness?

Sameness becomes a commercial problem when shoppers start choosing on price, or picking up the wrong pack. Watch for these signs:

  • Shoppers or buyers mistake your pack for a competitor's or a private label's.

  • Volume depends more and more on promotions.

  • With the logo covered, the pack could belong to anyone in the category.

  • Competitors copy your new claims within a season.

Heritage brands face a particular risk, because the pressure to look modern pulls them towards the category average. When IW renews an established brand, we first go through every asset, from logo and colours to typefaces and pack details. We decide whether each one should be kept, refined or joined by something new before anything is redrawn. More in how to modernise a heritage brand.

What does this mean for your brand?

  • Cover the logo. Place your pack next to its three closest competitors with the names hidden, and see whether people can still pick out yours.

  • List the category codes. Separate the cues that say what the product is from the cues that say who made it.

  • Break one code on purpose. Colour, shape or tone is often enough. Keep the cues that help people find the shelf.

  • Invest in assets before claims. Choose a colour, shape or character you can own, and use it everywhere for years.

  • Give the pack a feeling. The evidence from advertising shows that work built only on rational facts costs more to make effective. Emotional brands start ahead.

Frequently asked questions

What is brand sameness?

Brand sameness is when competing brands use the same colours, shapes, imagery and claims, so shoppers can't tell them apart quickly. It is most common in mature FMCG categories.

What is blandification in branding?

Blandification is an informal name for the drift towards safe, generic design that strips brands of character. It describes the same pattern as brand sameness.

How do you measure shelf standout?

Show shoppers your pack among competitors for a few seconds, with names hidden, and record how often and how fast they find it. Measuring the fame and uniqueness of each asset shows which ones actually carry the brand.

Does breaking category codes confuse shoppers?

It can if you break every code at once. Keep the cues that signal the category and change the ones that should signal your brand.

Do private labels make sameness worse?

Yes. Private labels that borrow a leader's colours and pack shapes make the whole shelf look more alike, so the leader's own assets need to be harder to copy.

How do you know if your brand looks like everyone else?

Sameness is hard to see from the inside, because the codes a brand shares with its competitors look like the category itself. The covered-logo test and an honest list of category codes show where your pack blends in.

If you want a second pair of eyes on your shelf, write to us at hello@iwagency.com.

Sources

IW Agency is a Stockholm brand agency working across strategy, design, communication, digital experience and innovation. Founded in 1992 as Identity Works.

Facing the same question?

Tell us what you are working on, and we will get back to you.

Get in touch →
Video